I propose the introduction of a new word: Railgunism: “The creation of a vastly superior spin-off, which erases and averts the flaws of the original and develops the potential of the setting and characters ignored by the original author”
(Image is Mikoto drawn by the Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai manga artist, Itachi.)
TheSpoonyOne addressed the issue of being able to level up while doing nothing in his FFX-2 review, but then again, I think that a lot of RPGs have some way to do that. Take Persona 4, for example. A game he likes. You can use Rush mode and those ‘Pringles’ monsters to trigger an infinite battle and haul in massive amounts of XP.
Despite that, I still love Spoony’s reviews. He may rage on the post-VII Final Fantasy games, games I personally like —even though I don’t know his opinion on my favourite of the bunch, XII—, but he never totally destroys them, even though any review of his about those games features at least one ‘THIS GAME IS TERRIBLE AND YOU SUCK FOR LIKING IT’ rant. He always adresses things he likes or admires about the game or its concept before tearing it apart.
His reviews always strike a perfect balance between representing his own opinion, representing an objective, general opinion and being funny or angry. That’s why I am never butthurt when watching him raging on a game I like. Because he is always reasonable, despite what he might say about people liking the thing being utter retards.
And finally, screw these rules. Have fun above all. If your disregard all of this, you still have the right to RP, as long as your enjoy it. Don’t force yourself to change. Finally, if you feel offended by this, don’t. This is advice is just my ideal, and I don’t mind if your ideal is totally different. In fact, you may be more right than I am. Just do whatever makes you feel good; what you and your RP buddies want to do.